Stephen King is known for his compelling storytelling and ability to craft suspenseful narratives that have captivated readers for decades. However, even the most celebrated authors aren’t immune to the passage of time. Some of King’s works contain moments that, when viewed through a modern lens, haven’t aged as well as others. Let’s delve into ten such instances where King’s writing, while brilliant, reveals elements that can seem outdated or problematic today.
1. Gender Stereotypes in “Carrie”
In “Carrie,” King’s debut novel, the portrayal of female characters can feel quite dated. The protagonist, Carrie White, is depicted through a lens of victimhood and fragility. While this was reflective of societal norms at the time, modern readers may find the depiction of Carrie’s mother as an abusive, fanatical figure and the stereotypical high school bullying problematic. The female experience is often oversimplified, which can be a point of contention for contemporary audiences seeking more nuanced representations.
2. Racist Tropes in “The Shining”
In “The Shining,” there are troubling stereotypes about Native American culture. The novel’s use of Native American symbolism and references to “Indian burial grounds” play into harmful clichés that can be seen as insensitive today. This reflects a broader issue in King’s early works where indigenous cultures are often used more as plot devices than as authentic representations.
3. Homophobic Undertones in “It”
“It” includes a subplot that, while pivotal to the story, features homophobic undertones. The character of the “homophobic bully” and some aspects of the depiction of the character Patrick Hockstetter can feel outdated. These portrayals can be uncomfortable for modern readers who are more aware of the need for respectful and accurate representations of LGBTQ+ individuals.
4. Outdated Gender Roles in “Misery”
“Misery” presents a stark representation of gender roles, with the character Annie Wilkes embodying the “crazy woman” trope. This portrayal reinforces negative stereotypes about women and mental illness. While the novel is a thrilling psychological study, it also reflects outdated attitudes towards female characters and their mental health.
5. Racial Stereotypes in “Pet Sematary”
“Pet Sematary” features a character named Jud Crandall who displays a number of racial stereotypes. The portrayal of the character’s “Indian” beliefs and practices can be seen as problematic by today’s standards. The use of cultural elements in ways that perpetuate stereotypes rather than celebrate genuine cultural diversity can feel insensitive.
6. Misogynistic Themes in “The Stand”
In “The Stand,” the role of women is often relegated to traditional or secondary positions. Female characters like Nadine Cross are portrayed through outdated stereotypes, reflecting the gender norms of the 1970s. This depiction can seem limiting and reflective of a time when women’s roles in literature were less progressive.
7. Insensitive Language in “Salem’s Lot”
“Salem’s Lot” contains instances of language that can be considered insensitive by modern standards. The casual use of derogatory terms and descriptions reflects the norms of the era in which it was written but can feel jarring to contemporary readers who are more attuned to issues of inclusivity and respect.
8. Stereotypes in “The Dark Tower” Series
“The Dark Tower” series is a beloved epic, but it includes problematic stereotypes, especially regarding the depiction of certain characters and cultures. The portrayal of certain groups in ways that reflect a lack of understanding or sensitivity can detract from the otherwise rich narrative.
9. Outdated Science Fiction Elements in “The Tommyknockers”
“The Tommyknockers” combines science fiction with horror, but some of its technological predictions and scientific explanations feel outdated. What was once seen as cutting-edge technology now seems quaint, reflecting the rapid advancements in science and technology that have occurred since the novel’s publication.
10. Ageist Views in “Gerald’s Game”
In “Gerald’s Game,” the protagonist’s internal dialogue often reflects ageist attitudes. The character’s self-perceptions and the way others view her due to her age can feel limiting and out of touch with contemporary views on aging and maturity.
Stephen King work remains influential and beloved, but like all art, it is a product of its time. While some moments haven’t aged well, they offer valuable insights into societal attitudes of the past and highlight the ongoing need for more inclusive and nuanced representations in literature. By examining these elements, we can better appreciate the progress made and continue to advocate for more respectful and diverse portrayals in literature.
For more such stories and articles, click here.
FAQs
1. Why do some moments in Stephen King’s books feel outdated?
Many of Stephen King’s books were written several decades ago, reflecting the societal attitudes and norms of that time. As societal values evolve, certain themes or portrayals in his work may seem outdated or problematic.
2. Are there any Stephen King books that haven’t aged well but are still worth reading?
Yes, despite some dated elements, many of King’s books remain compelling due to their storytelling and suspense. It’s often valuable to read them with a critical eye and an understanding of their historical context.
3. How can readers approach problematic content in classic literature?
Approaching problematic content with an understanding of its historical context can be helpful. It’s also important to engage in discussions about these issues and advocate for more inclusive and respectful representations in literature.
4. What can modern readers learn from outdated portrayals in older books?
Modern readers can gain insights into historical societal norms and attitudes, which helps in understanding the progress made in literature and broader social issues. It also underscores the importance of continuing to advocate for diversity and inclusion.
5. Will Stephen King address these outdated elements in his future works?
Stephen King has evolved as a writer, and many of his more recent works reflect a greater awareness of contemporary issues. While not all outdated elements may be addressed, King’s ongoing work often demonstrates a commitment to more inclusive and respectful storytelling.